Comments and Reactions to the Top 3 American Idol 2012 Performances by the American Idol Judges

The Top 3 American Idol contenders had performed and there were mixed reactions from the audience and fans.

Here are some comments and reactions of the 3 American Idol Judges, Randy Jackson, Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler, to the Top 3 Performances.

Joshua Ledet with “No More Drama”

  • Randy: “It doesn’t matter what you sing, you have laid everything on this stage.”
  • Jennifer: “You know exactly what you’re doing and letting completely go at the same time.”
  • Steven:  “That was beautiful. I felt the last 40 years in the music business.”

Joshua Ledet with “I’d Rather Go Blind”

  • Randy: You dig deep into the lyric and the meaning. Brilliant dude brilliant.”
  • Jennifer: “It was a controlled performance for you. You have an incredible instrument.”
  • Steven: “It was beautiful. Every time you sing you take it over the top.”

Joshua Ledet with “Imagine”

  • Randy: “You dig deep into the lyric and the meaning. Brilliant dude brilliant.”
  • Jennifer: “It was a controlled performance for you. You have an incredible instrument.”
  • Steven: “It was beautiful. Every time you sing you take it over the top.”

Jessica Sanchez singing with “I’ll be There”

  • Randy: “I liked it OK, I didn’t love it. There was never a moment, moment.”
  • Jennifer: “Perfect tone in your voice. You came back and killed it so hard at the end.”
  • Steven: “Perfect song, perfect voice. You nailed it.”

Jessica Sanchez with “I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing”

  • Randy: “It started a little slow. I was waiting on a big moment and dude you delivered!”
  • Jennifer: “That was amazing. That note at the end sent everyone into the heavens.”
  • Steven: “You just took a great song and made it greater. Beautiful.”

Jessica Sanchez with “My All”

  • Randy: “That was absolutely beautiful, perfectly the right song for you.”
  • Jennifer: “Hard song, but you did it so beautifully and you did it in your own way.”
  • Steven: “Jessica when you sing you make people hang on your every note.”

Phillip Phillips with “We Got Tonight

  • Randy: “The perfect song at the perfect time and your best performance on the show ever!”
  • Jennifer: “There are about 20 million girls out there who wish you were singing to them.”
  • Steven: “You just showed that you’ve got all that passion wrapped up inside of you.”

Phillip Phillips with “Disease”

  • Randy: “It was such a subdued moment from you. We need a bigger moment from you now.”
  • Jennifer: “That was an easy flowy performance. It was good.”
  • Steven: “It wasn’t over the top, but it was Phillip Phillips.”

Phillip Phillips with “Beggin”

  • Randy: “You are so in the zone and you have been in the zone since day one.”
  • Jennifer: “You catch a groove and you just ride that all the way home. It was great.”
  • Steven: “It’s so beautiful to watch you unfold. I’m hoping that you write your own songs.”

Tomorrow is judgment day for the Top 3 American Idols 2012 hopefuls. Who will make the cut for the Top 2 American Idols 2012 Finalists?

Check back on May 17 to know who would go home and who would be the Top 2 finalists who will perform on May 22 & 23 at the Nokia Live Theatre.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.